Time 2 Tell revolves around two friends who grew up as besties, yet were inherently different. One, a devout Bible believing Christian, and the other an athiest who refuses to see the logic of a loving God. The Christian designs a time machine to bring his buddy back to the time of Christ, and what transpires is an adventure that neither of them are prepared for.

Bombarded with issue after issue, they begin wrestling with a "Having to stay in the 1st Century" dilemma, Christian freaks out. As he slowly learns to trust his friend again, it appears they both discover that there just might be more to this "getting home" than being a freaked out atheist.